Rahul Gandhi pitches NYAY as a remedy to demonetisation ills; but can his idea work on the ground?


The Economist journal in an article titled “The war on penury”, displaying inside the Asia a part of the print model, talked about that the Nyuntam Aay Yojana (NYAY), hogging the pleasure of place in Congress’ election manifesto, could contribute to injustice “by stripping benefits from people striving to flee the underside fifth and rewarding people striving deceitfully to enter it.”

The Economist has hit the nail on the highest — NYAY could possibly be counterproductive. There could possibly be a mad scramble for coming into the gravy put together and since it rightly components out, deceit may play a large place given its potential to tantalise the indolent and the lazy and given the size of the dole in perpetuity. Out of the 5 crore family it’d purpose, a substantial amount would possibly, attributable to this reality, be charlatans.

The similar FP report moreover says Rahul Gandhi, who has been rationalising the patently unjustified, unsustainable and unimplementable scheme ever as a result of it was launched with numerous fanfare and with a contact of defiance to throw the gauntlet at and mock the BJP, justifies NYAY furthermore as a balm to nurse once more the demonetisation-ravaged poor once more into the financial nicely being. And he calls his enormous proposed dole remonetisation. Touché!

Rahul Gandhi pitches NYAY as a remedy to demonetisation ills; but can his idea work on the ground?

File image of Congress president Rahul Gandhi. PTI

Demonetisation occurred on eight November 2016. It did throw the monetary system, inured as a result of it was to cash, pell-mell for three months. But it surely certainly was on no account a sore degree with the voters as a result of the 2017 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections gave a decisive thumbs as a lot as Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s cataclysmic switch that faraway from hurting the poor, had for its purpose making the moneybags stew of their very personal juice.

And remonetisation occurred post-haste on the once more of demonetisation of Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 overseas cash notes that suck out as loads as 86 % of the overseas cash in circulation with freshly minted Rs 2,000 notes and newer mannequin of Rs 500 notes moving into the breach.

Even when one gives a charitable interpretation of the time interval ‘remonetisation’ to suggest compensating the poor for what was usurped from them by demonetisation, one is apt to shock how such a compensatory measure can proceed in perpetuity. When a gimmick is launched, it turns into very robust to justify it. Rationalisation, attributable to this reality, follows unabated in a method of hundred lies being uttered to justify the first.

Parenthetically, it is likely to be talked about that the outcomes of demonetisation are literally serendipitously and tangentially exhibiting up inside the run as a lot because the 2019 frequent elections. Massive parts of cash being unearthed via the income tax raids perhaps have their origins inside the tumultuous days following the demonetisation when sundry attorneys and crooks had been caught frenetically and feverishly laundering their demonetised overseas cash notes with the remonetised notes primarily of Rs 2,000 denomination.

In a method, it is a poetic justice for Prime Minister Modi, who has regularly been upbraided for launching demonetisation with out one thing to level out for it. These inside the know aver {{that a}} substantial part of the illegitimate money stashed up found its means into the banking system via shell companies that are beneath scrutiny now. And one different sliver of it was overtly remodeled into new remonetised notes in cahoots with pliable monetary establishment managers.

In a method, attributable to this reality, the large cache of notes now being made inside the run as a lot as the general elections is cache of the demonetised notes. Be that as it’d.

That it’s not a top-up scheme nevertheless a generous scoop or dollop of Rs 6,000 per 30 days, interval, for 5 crore matriarchs of poor households on the bottom of the heap would make it irresistible for charlatans to make it to the gravy put together by the hook or the felony. Topping up not lower than would have the benefit of slowing down the charlatans of their tracks — the onus could possibly be on them to indicate that they don’t have ample (Rs 12,000 per 30 days) income.

(The creator is a senior columnist and tweets @smurlidharan)


Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the latest analysis, commentary and data updates, be a part of our WhatsApp corporations. Merely go to Firstpost.com/Whatsapp and hit the Subscribe button.


Your data to the latest election data, analysis, commentary, keep updates and schedule for Lok Sabha Elections 2019 on firstpost.com/elections. Observe us on Twitter and Instagram or like our Facebook internet web page for updates from all 543 constituencies for the upcoming frequent elections.



Facebook Comments

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More