Narendra Modi govt’s Budget 2019 gives away a lot without taking anything; how’s the math working then?


The strategy to the Interim Funds has been attention-grabbing. As it’s an interim one, there was no unfavourable disruption induced within the tax charges. However the proposals have labored round decreasing the tax burden of people in any respect ranges. On the identical time expenditures have been elevated in all crucial areas with the rationale being that they’re required and can’t wait until June or July. This is without doubt one of the most enjoyable budgets as a result of it solely offers and doesn’t take something from anybody. Usually when concessions are given, somebody pays for it. However this time nobody pays for a similar because it has been labored out by way of the numbers. Allow us to see how this works.

The finances dimension has been elevated sharply by 13.5 % when previously it goes up by nearly 8-10 %. This gives a bigger leeway to offer funds in several areas. So the Funds has elevated expenditure on the switch of earnings to farmers by Rs 55,000 crore, subsidies by Rs 35,000 crore, MGNREGA by Rs 5,000 core and capex by Rs 20,000 crore. By retaining the fiscal deficit at 3.four % which is similar as in FY19 there may be no criticism in regards to the ultimate final result. General borrowings have elevated however the internet borrowing is simply Rs 50,000 crore over final 12 months which ought to pose no pressure on liquidity. Due to this fact, this is a perfect finances the place nobody is worse off and much are higher off.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi. PTI

Prime Minister Narendra Modi. PTI

A crucial balancing issue is disinvestment which has been elevated to Rs 90,000 crore with the revised quantity for FY19 being retained at Rs 80,000 crore as this may be doable solely in case there are inter-PSU purchases, the disinvestment programme has nearly grow to be one the place surpluses of PSUs get transferred to the federal government on this method. Due to this fact, any debate on whether or not the disinvestment quantity is credible or not is just not actually related because the goal will all the time be achieved.

An attention-grabbing commentary is that the non-tax income has additionally elevated with the dividend element going up from Rs 1.22 lakh crore FY19 (B) to Rs 1.19 lakh crore in FY19 (R) to Rs 1.36 lakh crore in FY20. This consists of a big half from banks, FIs and RBI which is to be Rs 83,000 crore in FY20. That is important as a result of as banks are making losses, the majority has to come back from the RBI which is able to in all probability pay an interim dividend or switch this 12 months and the next quantity subsequent 12 months. The indication is that the committee wanting into the reserves of RBI can have a narrative to inform which is able to mix with the requirement within the finances. Additionally, the truth that the finances makes no provision for PSB recapitalisation in FY20 means that when a choice is taken to switch RBI reserves to the federal government, they’d be used for this objective.

It’s comprehensible that no change has been invoked within the tax charges regarding corporates or the inventory market similar to LTCG as it will be left to the subsequent authorities. Nevertheless, the people, in addition to the SMEs, have been given a profit which is curious because it does result in a sure lack of income which is made up by stronger progress in earnings. That is in all probability the large wager the place it’s assumed that the GDP progress shall be swift, resulting in greater collections particularly on GST which is able to justify these tax cuts and better bills.

With the difficulty of fundamental earnings catching headlines, this finances has introduced it in by way of the backdoor by focusing on the marginal farmers and offering an earnings of Rs 6,000 each year for 12 crore of them. The outlay of Rs 75,000 crore is staggering and when mixed with Rs 60,000 crore beneath MGNREGA signifies that nearly 5 % of the general finances is now a money fee to farmers. It may be argued whether or not or not Rs 500 monthly means something as such for a household provided that even going by the outdated World Financial institution rule of $1 a day (it’s now $1.90), a household of 5 would require Rs 10,500 to be out of poverty. Therefore, at finest it is a complement and can’t be an earnings which might maintain a family. The silver lining is that if this may be efficiently applied then it could actually lay the inspiration of a long run scheme which is viable.

The federal government’s concentrate on capex has remained undiluted which is constructive and, at Rs 3.36 lakh crore, with concentrate on roads and railways, is commendable. However this can’t be anticipated to drive the economic system in an enormous approach and except there’s non-public funding forthcoming will once more add a delta to capital formation and never drive the initiative. It should be remembered that Rs lakh crore is on defence which could possibly be spent primarily on imports.

The finances is therefore a non-controversial one which has used some sturdy assumptions of progress to justify income collections despite the fact that solely advantages have been given. People can’t complain as a result of there are solely sops. Corporates have been left with a impartial affect and a few sectors could achieve if folks spend extra on particular items. On expenditure, the poor seem to realize and nobody loses and therefore is once more usually constructive in affect. General borrowing in internet phrases is not going to disturb the markets and liquidity, and therefore rates of interest will stay untouched. And if the numbers don’t add up in February 2020, the disinvestment block is all the time there which is able to assist the three.four % fiscal quantity. That is how one can view the Funds.

(The author is Chief Economist, Care Scores)

Click here to calculate your income tax

Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the newest evaluation, commentary and information updates, join our WhatsApp companies. Simply go to and hit the Subscribe button.


Facebook Comments

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More