Gujarat govt offers to play the umpire; suggests PepsiCo India make it a party to contracts with potato farmers


The Gujarat authorities “wants the best possible deal for farmers” and has advised PepsiCo India it might play the ‘umpire’ in its contract farming association with potato farmers, Gujarat’s Chief Secretary J N Singh stated.

Singh stated the corporate was paying ‘a very good value’ to farmers and the federal government wished the contract farming programme to go ‘easily’. He had prompt tripartite settlement “as a model,” the place the federal government could be a celebration to a contract between PepsiCo and potato farmers.

 Gujarat govt offers to play the umpire; suggests PepsiCo India make it a party to contracts with potato farmers

Representational picture. Reuters

Singh spoke to Firstpost after PepsiCo provided to withdraw the instances it had filed in opposition to 9 farmers and two traders-cum-farmers for allegedly utilizing its protected FL 2027 selection, which it sells below the commerce title FC 5. PepsiCo had sued some farmers for Rs 20 lakh every. From others it had sought damages of Rs 1.05 cr every. A PepsiCo govt stated the upper damages had been meant to quick monitor the litigation and never for financial acquire.

The FL 2027 selection was registered in america in February 2004 and enjoys safety there until February 2024. PepsiCo India Holdings commercialised the range in India in December 2009. It utilized for registration below the Safety of Plant Varieties and Farmers’ Rights (PPVFR) Act, 2001 in February 2011, two months after the PPVFR Authority allowed new forms of 11 crops together with potato to be registered. Registration for FC 2027 was granted in February 2016. It is going to stay protected in India until February 2031.

PepsiCo was pressured on the again foot by a backlash on social media. Greater than 190 organisations and people which declare to talk for farmers urged PepsiCo to take again its go well with. The corporate was additionally on weak grounds legally as a result of Indian legislation provides not simply exemptions from breeder’s rights to farmers but additionally active entitlements. Congress Celebration chief Ahmed Patel chided the corporate and the Gujarat authorities. PepsiCo felt remoted.

Moderately than threat additional harm to its fame, Pepsico India withdrew the litigation. This has been handed off as a triumph of the underdogs and a reminder to multinational firms that nevertheless excessive they is perhaps, the Indian legislation is above them.

Ashwani Mahajan, Co-Convenor of the Swadeshi Jagran Manch, an affiliate of the Sangh Parivar which helps financial nationalism tweeted that it was a “moral victory for farmers.”

Realising it was shedding the battle of perceptions, PepsiCo accepted the face-saver of a negotiated settlement which the Gujarat authorities provided. “We are relying on the said discussions to find a long-term and an amicable settlement to all issues around seed protection,” PepsiCo India stated in a press release.

If PepsiCo had endured with the litigation, a possibility would have been afforded to the courts to make clear the extent to which the entitlements of farmers might abridge the rights of breeders, a authorized govt at an Indian agricultural biotechnology firm with a portfolio of IPRs stated. The part of the PPVFR Act granting farmers the exemption to save lots of, share, alternate and promote produce and seed of even protected varieties (in an unbranded type) has not been legally examined, she stated.

The Act says farmers might be deemed to be entitled in the identical method as earlier than the legislation got here into pressure. The legislative intent, she stated, was to allow the customary observe of farmers utilizing saved seed for sowing. The courts would have been capable of say when a farmer promoting the seed of a protected selection turned a dealer.

PepsiCo is the most important procurer of chips-quality potatoes. It buys three lakh tonnes yearly from 24,000 contract growers. It paid about Rs 10 a kg within the final season. That will have resulted in a switch of Rs 300 crore to farmers. The sued farmers weren’t on contract to PepsiCo India. In the event that they wished to provide chips-quality potatoes to PepsiCo’s rivals they’ve a alternative of non-protected varieties like Woman Rosetta, ATL or Atlantic and Chipsona 1, 2, and three.

PepsiCo India executives say they’ve been promoting in native newspapers that FC 5 is protected. They’ve distributed pamphlets in villages to create consciousness and in addition advised chilly storages to not inventory FC 5, which is supposed for is captive use.

Representational image. Reuters

Representational picture. Reuters

PepsiCo India had provided to purchase FC 5 produce from the sued farmers and invited them to turn out to be its contract growers the following season. It had bought FC 5 seed to its contract growers at Rs 20-25 a kg relying on measurement and had introduced produce from them at about Rs 10 a kg.

PepsiCo India executives say FC 5 provides it a aggressive benefit. It’s higher-yielding, has the next proportion of dry matter and decrease proportion of decreasing sugars. However Vinay Bhardwaj, Head of Crop Enchancment on the Central Potato Analysis Institute (CPRI), Shimla, says ATL was higher in some respects. Ismail Sheru, a contract grower in Banaskantha of French fry-quality potatoes for McCain, a Canadian provider to McDonald’s was additionally of the identical opinion.

PepsiCo’s charges had been just like these provided by Hyfun Frozen Meals, which has 1,200 farmers on contract and procured 62,000 tonnes of potatoes within the final season. The corporate has a processing plant at Mehsana and provides French fries to Burger King and KFC. It charged Rs 26 a kg for seed and paid Rs 9 a kg for potatoes on the farm gate.

The backstory is that Fulchand Kachchhava, the Managing Director of Tirupati Balaji Potato Chip, an organization that procures potatoes for Balaji Wafers is orchestrating the agitation. The corporate’s registered workplace is in Deesa, Banaskantha. Kachchhava and his brother, who’re additionally potato growers, had been among the many 11 who had been sued.

Kachchhava admitted to Firstpost that he was procuring 40,000 tonnes of potatoes. He had purchased on the charge of Rs 9.50-10 a kg. These had been each cooking selection and chip high quality. He stated he glided by the traits of potatoes and never their commerce names. He denied backing the sued farmers or participating a PR company to smear PepsiCo. “I don’t know what a PR agency is,” he asserted.

Kachchhava stated farmers had been agitated by PepsiCo motion. Until it withdrew the fits, farmers’ unions have determined to proceed with the ‘seed andolan‘ or protest at its potato assortment factors. They may even boycott its contract farming programme, he added.

Contract farming is sweet for farmers. It provides them the reassurance of costs. India needs to encourage it. It has drafted a mannequin legislation for the states to enact. Farmers additionally acquire from hand-holding in good agronomic practices.

PepsiCo says it encourages sustainable practices like water-saving drip and sprinkler irrigation, the appliance of exact portions of liquid fertilisers and using labour and cost-saving machines for planting, spraying and harvesting.

Within the late 1980s, when PepsiCo sought a license to ply its delicate drinks enterprise in India, the federal government made horticultural improvement a pre-condition. Beneath the management of Ramesh Vangal, PepsiCo India arrange a tomato processing plant in Punjab. It received farmers to develop tomatoes below contract. The varieties they planted had been tall with fruit at varied phases of ripening. These might be plucked manually with household labour.

Because the harvesting was in instalments and never in a single go, the processing plant was smaller than within the developed nations—acceptable for a rustic with scarce and costly capital. The pasteurised paste was of a high quality that was acceptable to the finicky Japanese market. PepsiCo additionally launched methods like deep chiselling to interrupt the laborious pan that was shaped about two ft beneath the floor in Punjab’s fields as a result of compaction by tractors. This allowed crops to entry underlying vitamins.

One other contract purchaser, McCain, additionally modified the best way potatoes had been grown within the Banaskantha area. Earlier than it started its operations in 2006, farmers would flood irrigate their fields. They’d faucet into the aquifers recharged by the River Banas. The water used over the course of a four-month interval, from sowing to harvesting, if stacked, would rise to a column about two ft excessive.

McCain transformed the farmers to micro-irrigation. With info supplied by its climate stations, its brokers within the subject would inform them when to irrigate and the way a lot. Not solely was water saved however pests and ailments attributable to humidity decreased. Jalgaon in Maharashtra has turn out to be a banana hub due to Jain Irrigation. The state is the second largest producer of bananas. Jain Irrigation promoted the cultivation of the fruit by means of a mixture of tissue tradition, drip irrigation and fertigation. It changed conventional varieties with the high-yielding Grand Naine from Israel within the early 1990s.

Whereas talking at a gathering of the Asia-Pacific Rural and Agricultural Credit score Affiliation in Delhi in December 2017, NITI Aayog Member (Agriculture) Ramesh Chand stated the involvement of firms was important for worthwhile and modern agriculture. However their share in agricultural funding at 2 p.c was very low in comparison with that of farmers (84 p.c) and the federal government (14 p.c).

India’s milk revolution was caused by Amul’s contract dairy farming and the Inexperienced Revolution in north-west India was because of the value, procurement and hand-holding assist given by the Indian authorities.

Will probably be a hole victory for farmers if firms like PepsiCo India who profit farmers by means of contract farming preparations are painted as villains for making an attempt to guard their mental property.

(The creator is a senior journalist.  He tweets @smartindianagri)


Firstpost is now on WhatsApp. For the newest evaluation, commentary and information updates, join our WhatsApp providers. Simply go to and hit the Subscribe button.


Your information to the newest election information, evaluation, commentary, stay updates and schedule for Lok Sabha Elections 2019 on Comply with us on Twitter and Instagram or like our Facebook web page for updates from all 543 constituencies for the upcoming basic elections.


Facebook Comments

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More